Reading AI Literature

It seems the concern of AI is to whether it is good or evil. Will it take over the world?

This is not my concern.

Like speculative fiction, I see it as an abstract concept to consider the embodiment of human intelligence into capital – an objectifying capital opposed to human life and labor.

Inevitably, all the intelligence in AI is drawn up like water into and becomes artificial. There must also be a conversation on what happens to the human after their intelligence is drawn away. Are we at this point now where we are seeing “the machine” as more powerful than the human in the everyday? Not more powerful in muscle, but more powerful in its dominance, controlling the “human cultural process.”

Culturally we become assembled and hybrid with computers. (Although, seeing it as hybridity, I supposed we’ve been hybrid for all of time).

The Veridic

For more on the concept of The Veridic, see Julian Raxworthy

So much of garden writing: So much of gardening is about “The Plants.” Unique plants. People love the plants. Collecting. I mean – I can identify, as genus and species, more ornamental plants than anyone I know (I don’t know very many people) but the work I do with other people’s homes and gardens – landscapes… The plants are about what is available in the market. Production. Agriculture. I create compositions. Use materials. Create and define spaces. Lengthy treatises on plant propagation and plant lists are of no concern. We create “The Land.” We develop. Landscape. There is brick, stone, concrete, glass, plastics, and lumber – and then there is not necessarily differentiated masses and planes of lignin and cellulose – plant matter:- The Veridic.

Social Forms.

Capitalism – the name we have given to a form of social relations. While these forms of relations can be mapped out and are real and concrete, and we can name them as we wish, inevitably these forms are fluid, not fixed. As with Socialism; an imagined form of relations; can only become through the same historical process as capitalism; fluid – The only hard points or moments are the images of that history itself. Social forms soft, move, transform, temperate.

Revolution. Distribution. Process.

As the revolution against Capitalism – post WWII – becomes about distribution, social(ist) planning, and reform, “Marxist Analysis” of culture and structure looses its force, mandate, and fails to keep pace with change.

I have seen in my reading the past year that says the recent interest in “The Left” and “revolution” draw momentum from large contemporary movements such as Black Lives Matter. Surely there are a number of voices of analysis on this front but it seems the popular belief sees the foundations of these issues as distribution oriented (although I can see real quickly how this needs to be transformed into a process conversation – distribution conversations and analysis are dead and cliche).

“De-Fund the Police.” Of course we mean this as process, but I suspect that generally people can only understand it as distributional.

Tasks For Further Study.

1. Review N+1 review of New Left histories, early 2022.

2. Review introduction and conclusion/post script of Terence Renaud’s “New Left”

3. Spend some time at library – find “The Rise of The New Left.”

4. Re-read Marx’s “The Labor Process” in Capital

5. Begin surveying readings on AI

T

Braverman Summary: Absence of a History of Labor Process Study

Marx’s Capital shows how The Labor Process, the production process of society, is constantly transformed, driven by that society’s principle force – the accumulation of capital.

At the time of Braverman’s writing in the early 70s, Braverman claims no historical work has been done on this since Marx. The analytical work of “Marxism” was dominated by 20th century topics of proletarian revolution, depressions, crisis’ of capitalism, militarism, imperialism, and nationalism. Later in the century, working class consumption weakened the revolutionary drive to take control of production from capital and “turned ever more to bargaining over labor’s share in the product” (p10). Criticism of the mode of production gave way to critiques of distribution.

(See also: Renaud, Terence. New Lefts: The Making of a Radical Tradition)

Our Story Of Capital

The conversation and analysis, as always, takes the direction of “Yes. This is the injustice of the system! You have an intelligent and skilled person and then “capital” takes their skills and builds it into a machine. Then the worker is replaced by the machine or a less expensive operator and the capitalist gets all the money. The rich keep getting richer and richer as everything becomes more mechanized and automated!!!”

This narrative goes on and on and everyone is outraged of course. But. There is another macroscopic issue to attend to. We have to stop and return to the beginning. We have to consider the person who had their intelligence and skill taken from them. Generations of skill and intelligence (skill/intelligence, same thing).

With each passing generation, a new generation of skills is taken up and embodied into capital. Capital accumulates the skills and intelligence.

With each passing generation our relationship to the real becomes more abstract.

Salad Value

When Nicki asked about the salad, I did my best to explain it like this:

“Nick. You work in “The Kitchen,” in a certain tradition. I think when people come to your restaurant, they come looking to spend their money on something they could not do themselves. They come looking for skill, provisions outside their access and knowledge, creativity and(/or) a dialogue with the ‘culinary literature.”

“On the other hand, sometimes what we are looking for is the luxury of not having to do the work ourselves. “

“In this case, I could have made a better salad at home, but it was a great value and the did an excellent job of providing that.”

Patricia Layman Bazelon

Patricia Layman Bazelon

Patricia Layman Bazelon was born and educated in England and immigrated to the USA in 1961, working as a television producer in Manhattan during the 1960’s and 1970’s. In 1979 she moved to Buffalo and began working as a free-lance architectural photographer.

It was during this time she met British architectural historian, Reyner Banham, who commissioned her to photograph the many grain elevators and industrial buildings for his book, A Concrete Atlantis. Bazelon fell in love with Buffalo’s industrial architecture and continued to photograph it extensively.

Although she returned to New York in 1988 to become the chief photographer for the Brooklyn Museum, she continued to photograph Buffalo’s industrial architecture until her untimely death in the summer of 1995. 

Bazelon’s photographs of Buffalo’s grain elevators and the Bethlehem Steel Plant are in many collections, including the Burchfield Penney Art Center, Buffalo, NY; George Eastman House International Museum of Photography, Rochester, NY; The West Collection, St. Paul, Minn.; The Castellani Art Museum, Niagara Falls, NY; and the Brooklyn Museum, NY.


That Must Be It.

Image

I came across this image in Reyner Banham’s “A Concrete Atlantis”(1986).  The caption read:

“Brick-pier-construction factory at Grosvenor and North Division, Buffalo, New York (destroyed by explosion, 1984). (Photo, Bazelon)”

“Destroyed by explosion”. I of course jumped to the December 27th, 1983 “Division Street Explosion,” where a forklift operator was carrying around a propane tank, it fell over, and broke off the valve. Propane leaked everywhere. The fire department was called. A standard full alarm was dispatched – 3 engines, 2 ladders or trucks, and a Battalion Chief. As the propane slowly crept its way around the floor of the building the first trucks arrived. Battalion Chief called in “on location” and thirty-seven seconds later that propane found an ignition source. The explosion picked up the first Engine and threw it thirty feet into a wall across the street. It did the same to Truck 5. Five fireman died instantly.

“Destroyed by explosion” I remembered only because my grandfather was Buffalo Fire and had retired 10 days before. I was only 8.

I thought “Destroyed by explosion” was that building.

I don’t believe this to be the case anymore. Buffalo Fire accounts suggest the building was “timber frame.” Banham’s photo is discussing “Brick-pier-construction.” It turns out more than one building was destroyed.

“It completely leveled the four-story building. It demolished many buildings on four different blocks. It seriously damaged buildings that were over a half a mile away. The ensuing fireball started buildings burning on a number of streets. A large gothic church on the next block had a huge section ripped out of it as if a great hand carved out the middle. A ten-story housing projects a couple blocks away had every window broken and some had even more damage. Engine 32 and Truck 5′s firehouse, which was a half mile away or so, had all its windows shattered.”